Monitoring leave of Absence Abuse

Monitoring leave of Absence Abuse: A recent decision from the 6th Circuit in the matter of in Seeger v. Cincinnati Bell may change the landscape of HR absence related investigations and the ability of employers to better defend their use of investigative techniques to protect themselves from employee related fraud. In the Seeger case, the employer

After completing their investigation, the employer suspended Seeger and ultimately fired him for “disability fraud,” stating that he had “over-reported” his symptoms to avoid the part-time light-duty work that the company’s paid-leave policy required. Seeger sued, claiming retaliation for taking FMLA leave. He reported that his doctor directed him to engage in some limited physical activity that the company learned of during the investigations and that the company should be held liable for firing him for doing what his doctor prescribed.

The question, the court said, was not if Seeger actually committed fraud, but if the company “reasonably and honestly” believed that he did.

Based on the thoroughness of its investigation, the court said the company met was protected under the “honest belief rule”:

As long as an employer has an honest belief in its proffered nondiscriminatory reason for discharging an employee, the employee cannot establish that the reason was pretextual simply because it is ultimately shown to be incorrect. An employer has an honest belief in its reason for discharging an employee where the employer reasonably relied on the particularized facts that were before it at the time the decision was made.

 

Affiliations

Accredited PBSA
ACFE
FCRA
NAPBS
NCISS
PBSA

Private Investigation News & Alerts

Difficulties Conducting Surveillance: Obstacles Faced by Private Investigatorsprivate investigator ethics policy
Surveillance is a critical task for private investigators, enabling them to gather vital information and evidence, in a format that is almost undisputable. However, conducting surveillance can be...read more ❯
The Role and Responsibilities of a Private InvestigatorResponsibilities of a private investigator
Private investigators often capture our imagination, as their work seems to mirror the thrilling world of detective novels and movies. However, beyond the allure of mystery and intrigue lies a...read more ❯
Can a Private Investigator Help You Locate a Loved One?
The number of missing persons each year in the U.S. has significantly decreased since 1997. And yet, there were still over 521,000 missing person cases in 2021. The reasons for the missing persons...read more ❯